The first time I heard about “Flock of Dodos,” I immediately thought of the ongoing battle on “Friends” between Ross and Phoebe about evolution.
Ross: You don’t believe in evolution?
Phoebe: I don’t know, it’s just…you know, monkeys, Darwin…you know, it’s a…it’s a nice story. I just think it’s a little too easy.
Ross: Too easy? Too….the process of every living thing on this planet evolving over millions of years from single-celled organisms is… is too easy?
Phoebe: Yeah, I just don’t buy it.
Ross: Uh, excuse me, evolution is not for you to buy, Phoebe. Evolution is scientific fact, like…like…like the air we breathe. Like gravity.
Phoebe: Oh, okay, don’t get me started on gravity…
Thankfully, the participants in the debates between the two predominant viewpoints within “Flock of Dodos” – Evolutionists vs. Intelligent Designers – tend to be a little bit more open-minded. (There is, however, one tale of a Creationist telling a woman that, because she’s an Episcopalian, she’s going to burn in Hell…but, then, as an Episcopalian myself, I expect she’s used to hearing that by now. We get that all the time.)
Randy Olson is a filmmaker. He’s also an evolutionary biologist, although he hasn’t actively worked in the field for a few years. When his mom began writing him from his home state of Kansas, keeping him informed about various school board battles involving evolution and intelligent design, it spurred Olson to make a film which posed a few questions, first and foremost being, “If we’re so unabashedly certain that evolution is a fact, then why is it still called a theory?” Next up: “What’s the deal on this whole ‘intelligent design’ thing, and is it really as viable as its proponents would have us believe?”
Olsen delivers an interesting, entertaining look at the battle between science and religion, interrupting the intelligent discourse on occasion with animation and caricatures to lighten the mood. Sometimes, however, valuable information can be delivered in a humorous manner, such as when the question is posed that if there’s truly an intelligent designer to the creatures on this planet, then why do rabbits have to eat something, poop it, and then eat it again for it to be properly digested? (True story…and they even show it!) It’s almost a running joke about how the intelligent design folk like to utilize Mt. Rushmore as an example of something that you’d look at and say, “Well, obviously, this thing was designed by someone,” only to follow by suggesting that the same could be said of any mountain, since you can’t disprove the concept. Fair enough…I guess.
As someone who lives in the same area as Pat Robertson, Regent University, and “The 700 Club,” you’d think I’d feel the hot breath of the creationists breathing down my neck even as I’m writing this very review, but, in fact, filmmaker / evolutionary biologist Randy Olson isn’t sporting devil horns during the course of his documentary…or, in other words, he’s not the Michael Moore of his subgenre. He’s a nice guy with a good sense of humor who doesn’t have an in-your-face attitude about his beliefs, and for the most part, the Intelligent Design folk that he’s chatting with come across a nice people, too. (The exception to that rule tends to come up whenever The Discovery Institute enters the picture.) He tries not to browbeat the people he’s talking with, and for their part, they generally try to hold polite conversations with him, even though they don’t agree with each other. In the end, Olsen politely suggests that the Intelligent Designers suffer from a tendency to examine their premise with their heart without factoring science into the equation…and while I’m of the mind that people are welcome to their own beliefs, I have to say that I’m in Olson’s camp.
But, then, as an Episcopalian, I’m apparently already going to Hell, anyway, so it’s not like I’m really going out on a limb.
P.S. There’s a lot more discussion on the topic amongst the special features of the DVD. Count on this becoming a staple of college biology classes in future years.



