Former “That 70’s Show” star Wilmer Valderrama, reputed first love of Lindsay Lohan, reportedly showed up at 2:30AM at a karaoke party Lindsay was attending in New York, and attempted to woo her back by serenading her with a Matchbox 20 tune.

Lohan did not respond positively to these overtures from the man who broke her heart just a few short years ago…though she was overheard mentioning to a friend that Fez might have had slightly better odds if he had chosen a song by a band that didn’t suck.