Old Show, New Season (sort of): “Nip/Tuck”
Chalk it up to another case of there simply not being enough hours in the day, but the truth of the matter is that I’ve never watched a single episode of “Nip/Tuck” until now…and since this is the second half of the show’s next-to-last season, it’s probably not exactly the best time for me to decide to get involved in the adventures of Drs. Sean McNamara and Christian Troy. The decision, however, came as a result of two simultaneous events: Ross Ruediger’s review of the first half of the 5th season, which was just released on DVD, and the arrival of a screener of the first episode of the second half of the 5th season. Stupid ol’ Ross. If his positive review of “Criminal Minds: Season 2″ hadn’t introduced me to that show, then I wouldn’t be trusting his opinion of “Nip/Tuck,” but when the guy describes it as “tasteless, vulgar, trashy, over-the-top fare that most people probably don’t care to admit they enjoy,” then I’m left wondering why I never took a chance on it before now.
And with that, let us hit “play” on “Ronnie Chase,” the first new “Nip/Tuck” of 2009.

The use of the O’Jays’ “Backstabber” within the opening sequence is inspired, as is the Mark Ronson cover of “Stop Me If You Think That You’ve Heard This One Before,” since what we’re watching is, after all, more or less an expanded flashback to events which occurred during the last episode of the season’s first half. After we catch up to the cliffhanging moment where Sean was lying in a pool of his own blood, things move pretty fast. Christian and Liz manage to keep Annie from crashing, and even after being dragged from the operating room into his office by Colleen, Sean successfully extracts revenge on his crazed assailant and keeps the show from becoming “Misery: The Series.” But poor Doc McNamara is in bad shape: as Christian arrives and tells his partner to hold on, Sean groans, “I can’t feel my legs.”
Suddenly, it’s four months later…and Sean’s doing his best Ironside impression, making his appearance by rolling out of an elevator in a wheelchair.
Technically, Sean’s reached a point where he ought to be able to return to surgery, but he’s got a nasty case of the jitters, so much so that he can’t even bring himself to assist with Liz’s breast surgery. Yes, you read that right: Liz is the patient this time. The weirdness of the situation makes for a funny but awkward scene where she begrudgingly opens her blouse to a decidedly inappropriate look of lechery from Christian, but it quickly turns serious when he finds something that feels like a lump. As it turns out, it is one. Thankfully, it’s an inoffensive issue caused by too much caffeine and diet soda…but suddenly Christian realizes that he, too, has a lump. I can guarantee that every female “Nip/Tuck” viewer will be grinning with glee during his mammogram, thinking, “At last, the tables are turned!” Unfortunately, the doctor doesn’t have the same kind of cheery revelation for Christian than he did for Liz.

Sean continues his rehab while teaching the ropes to a bunch of newly-graduated plastic surgeons (including one played by Adhir Kalyan from “Aliens in America,” who - maybe not coincidentally - is also named Raj here), and for a change, he gets good news from his son, Matt, who’s trying to get his ducks in a row for once and enrolling in community college. Even so, Sean’s anger at his inability to walk is easily matched by Christian’s concerns over his diagnosis of Stage 2 breast cancer, which means that tensions are running high. Fortunately, the two have a few drinks, play a few rounds of darts, and have a surprisingly sentimental scene where Sean talks about the dream he had of the future. Sure, Christian initially poo-poohs it, saying, “It was a dream, not a prophecy,” but then he admits that he’s scared and even begins to cry for a moment. Don’t worry, the show hasn’t gone soft: moments later, Christian manages to use his diagnosis as a pick-up line, God love him. The punchline…? In the middle of getting his rocks off, he asks the woman when she last had a breast exam. Sean, meanwhile, proceeds to utilize his wheelchair in a most impressive manner, proving conclusively that, at least in his case, being unable to walk doesn’t mean you’re dead from the waist down.
The final scenes of the episode find Christian undergoing surgery and Sean attending Colleen’s funeral (”to make sure she’s dead”), but the latter turns out to be a vaguely creepy dream sequence that causes Sean to decide that, by God, he’s ready to walk again. In the end, however, both of the doctors end up standing in front of their respective mirrors, looking at the scars that life has brought to them.

Obviously, my limited experience with “Nip/Tuck” means that I have no frame of reference to how this episode holds up within the context of the series as a whole, but as a first-time viewer, it contained enough action, drama, humor, and sex to keep me interested. But for you regulars, how did it hold up for you?
Posted in: Reviews, TV, TV Dramas
Tags: Christian Troy, Dylan Walsh, FX, Julian McMahon, Nip/Tuck, Nip/Tuck Season 5, Nip/Tuck second half Season 5, Sean McNamara


Buy or rent the previous 5 seasons you wont be dissapointed its that good of a show.
I watched the premiere last night and thought it was a good start. I got so sick of the Colleen storyline last season and was happy to see her (mostly) gone for good. It’s time to move on.
I had a different take on Sean’s ability to walk at the end. I got the impression that he had been faking all along — to gain sympathy, to get out of surgery, whatever. I guess we’ll find out next week if I’m right.
I also found it odd that they didn’t expand further on what happened after Sean’s beautiful student rolled him out of the building. Maybe they’re just setting that up for something later on in the season.
I thought the premiere was a great start and I am ready for next week’s episode. I also had a different take on Sean’s ability to walk at the end. Earlier in the episode, Sean and Matt were working on his “Hour of physical rehab.” If he needs an hour of physical rehab per day, that would make for a slow recovery. I don’t think you can just jump up and decide to walk in those types of situations.
Also, I recommend purchasing the first 3 seasons. I believe season 3 focuses on “The Carver” throughout the episodes and is, BY FAR, my favorite season.
My biggest problem with 5.15 was all that business about retconning the episode “Conor McNamara 2025″ (or whatever it was called) from S4 into a dream. That was such BS - but I’ve come to deal with this series on an ep by ep basis, because even when it all goes pear-shaped, they manage to swing it back around into something more than watchable.
Other than that gripe, along with 5.16, it’s been “Nip/Tuck” business as usual, and it will be interesting to see what they do with this shortened, 8-episode “mini-season.”
I do disagree with Brandon about S3, however - I especially loathed the last episode of that season with a passion, and it ended up making the rest of season seem really hollow in hindsight. What nonsense. In some ways the Carver was the best thing ever to happen to N/T, and in other ways the concept was the worst.
But Will - and I know you don’t really have the time to go back and check them out - someday you really should see the first two seasons for sure. Incredible TV.